10 reviews for Pencil Eyeliner by Revlon, ColorStay Eye Makeup with Built-in Sharpener, Waterproof, Smudgeproof, Longwearing with Ultra-Fine Tip, 201 Black, 0.01 Oz

1. 

   5 out of 5

   MechanicallyPinkMechanicallyPink – March 25, 2020

   A lot of people may use this for their eyes but I use it as my eyebrow pencil. It’s long lasting and doesn’t smear. Buying this pencil in store was starting to become a nuisance because it is a very popular pencil especially in the darker colors. I’m so happy they sale this on amazon. I purchase about 5 of them so it should be me for awhile! I pencil my eyebrows in with this pencil everyday and one last about two weeks to a month.

2. 

   5 out of 5

   MollyMolly – April 15, 2020

   My absolute favorite eyeliner ever. It’s really all I use! I buy if off Amazon now because in my state the drug stores jacked up the price.It’s straight, solid black and lasts almost all day before any noticeable fading occurs. Plus it’s easy to apply, you just have to get used to the amount of pressure you use, since the tip can break with too much. THE ONLY THING IS that this is a waterproof eyeliner, so you need makeup pads that specifically remove waterproof products. (I’ve used Neutrogena and Olay brand pads, both work fine, it’s whatever is cheaper or preferable.)

3. 

   5 out of 5

   Rose – June 26, 2020

   I’ve been through a lot of different eyeliner brands but my favorite for a long time was the Lancôme Lé stylo- inevitably I ended up looking for a more cost effective brand and came upon an article about Joanna Gaines and her tried and true favorite eyeliner…Revlon Colorstay…so of course I had to try it. I’ve been using it now for about 6 months and LOVE it!

4. 

   5 out of 5

   lori – July 12, 2020

   I got (4) of this product in two different colors. 2 for my niece & 2 for myself. The sapphire & black work amazing!! My niece is just getting the hang of the eyeliner thing lol. These are making it easy to teach her <3 (Greatest gift ever) After reading some of the reviews WoW I Have to include this. Beauty School & Makeup School 101 Temperature has everything to do with using the sharpening type of eyeliner. The same goes for the twist. Most people (not all) keep things like this in the bathroom right? Well, when people take those long HOT showers or baths it causes the product to swell. When the temp goes back to normal it causes it to shrink/dry out. For example, a lip gloss, stick, balm is in your bag in an area with heat or sun-exposed. What happens? A freaking hot mess lol My point is try keeping your makeup in a sealed makeup bag AWAY from varying temperatures.

5. 

   5 out of 5

   Lavender1234 – July 16, 2020

   I have been using this eyeliner for about 8 years or longer. I’ve tried so many other brands, befor and after…and nothing compares. My eyelids tend to get oily and I’m not the kind of girl who likes to reapply and touch up all day long. This lasts! It doesn not bleed or smear. Try this and never waste your money on more expensive brands…it’s an eyeliner…not a shirt. No one will know if it’s drugstore or Christian Dior. Save your money on your clothes, shoes, and accessories. That’s the beauty of makeup.

6. 

   5 out of 5

   jessica – July 16, 2020

   I have purchased expensive eyeliners that are not as good as this. In the last few years, I only buy this particular eyeliner. It might sound strange, but I use it for my eye brows as well because it doesn’t smudge easily and the color is perfect. I highly recommend this product to try out.

7. 

   5 out of 5

   Zee – August 1, 2020

   It works… my skin is more oily than dry and it stayed on. I work from 9-5 and now n then I’ll wipe my eyes more out of habit more than anything and usually by the end of the day I would be make up free, because my finger would rub the make up off. I used to use STELLA, but I was tire of the liquid liner and wanted something affordable and not liquid that would stay on my face. This eye liner stays on I’ll wipe my eyes and my finger is clean ☺️ I’m so happy with this product .

8. 

   5 out of 5

   FlickRN3 – August 22, 2020

   I’ve tried a few others but this one suits my needs. It has a sharpener but rather than use it (because it seems to waste the product) I just advance the eyeliner and wipe it back and forth on a tissue to get a great point. It doesn’t last all day but it is easy to refresh by adding more into the spaces where it was wearing off. I love it and will keep using this product and it doesn’t irritate my easily irritated eyelids.

9. 

   5 out of 5

   YogiB – January 11, 2021

   While it may take a practiced, steady hand in applying any eyeliner. This is pencil is easily corrected using a correction pen. I much prefer this over a liquid eyeliner. Glides on easily but remember to keep it capped because once it dries it will not transfer to the skin well. Try it. I like it over dept store brands.

10. 

    5 out of 5

    kstars – February 18, 2021

    More for less.I have tried many a eyeliner pencil. Revlon Colorstay is for me quite nice. The color does melt, but at least this pencil has a lot of color for in-between my eyelashes. I put it on in a way that it won’t bleed onto my under eye area. I just angle the pencil down along the lash line. Not over or under. There is a slight bit of irritation, but it goes away. I only do this 1. If I am out at a special occasion – for some oomph. 2. I know I will not be crying as at a theatre.This has concentrated color, and as a base under eyeshadow powders it holds better.I recommend this.